Update: Hart Says He Has No Remorse Over Stabbing; Claims Victim Raped Him In Prison
BVI Platinum News
Updated: August 01, 2012 8:11 am AST
Published: July 28, 2012 3:54 pm AST
Matthew Hart
Photo Credit: Melissa Edwards/BVI Platinum News
The man accused in Friday's Road Town Festival Village stabbing has told Police that he has no remorse for the victim, who he claims raped him repeatedly while he was an inmate at Her Majesty's Prison.

Appearing in court yesterday, July 30, Matthew Hart, 34, was not allowed to plea to the charge of inflicting grievous bodily harm. The sitting Magistrate remanded him to prison and a psychiatric evaluation is expected to be conducted on the accused. He will return to court on August 31.

Senior Crown Counsel Christlyn Benjamin told the court that Hart is a BVIslander and performs labourer type jobs for a living, but is of no fixed place of abode.

Benjamin said it is alleged that on Friday, July 27, the complainant was at the Road Town Festival Village when he was approached by the defendant whom he knew before. She said Hart asked the complainant for money, but the complainant refused to adhere to his request.

The court heard that Hart became upset and as the complainant turned around to walk away, Hart used a knife which he had in his possession to stab the complainant in the upper right side of his back.

Benjamin said the wound from the knife punctured the complainant's lung and he collapsed to the ground shortly after being wounded.

She stated that Hart then fled, but was apprehended a short while later by Police Officers with the said knife still in his possession.

When cautioned by the officers, Hart allegedly replied, "I stab he; he raped me nuff times in prison. I shoulda kill he; he shoulda dead."

The Prosecutor said a tape recorded interview was subsequently conducted with the defendant, who confessed to wounding the complainant with a knife, but expressed no remorse.

She told the court that the complainant suffered a collapse lung as a result of the wound and is presently admitted to the Peebles Hospital under stable, but serious condition.
-----
Copyright 2011 by Virgin Islands Platinum News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Comment | Report Abuse
The government is developing the region and overlooking the mentally ill. Why isn't there a facility for the mentally ill? These persons should not be housed in prison to be victimized. Our government are not doing right by these people and many of them are living in our parks and behind... more
August 05 at 8:32am  |  Like3 People like this.   Dislike
If Matthew was raped in prison and he told the prison guards about it and they did nothing about it then, heads need to roll. If this turns out to be true, then it is wrong. The big question is, why he single out this man. Matthew asked other people to buy him a drink and they refused, he did... more
August 01 at 11:13pm  |  Like22 People like this.   Dislike1 Person dislike this.
Blank | Report Abuse
Who did he stab anyway? Was that person in prison at anytime while Matthew was there? If so then there just might be some truth to what he's saying...
August 01 at 1:55pm  |  Like15 People like this.   Dislike1 Person dislike this.
Be fair | Report Abuse
So everyone here can identify known crack heads, yet the police can never seize any cocaine. Coincidence?
August 01 at 12:19pm  |  Like5 People like this.   Dislike1 Person dislike this.
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!! | Report Abuse
Could you believe matthew did reported that he was raped and the officers did nothing about it??? Maybe that's why he took it into his own hands.. IDK only God knows
August 01 at 11:03am  |  Like6 People like this.   Dislike
Home grown | Report Abuse
Is this the first-time that Matthew is talking about being raped? If so why didn't he report it?
August 01 at 8:49am  |  Like4 People like this.   Dislike3 People dislike this.
Blank | Report Abuse
Do you really think it's that easy for a man to report that he was raped? Not saying it's true, it's left to be proven. But if it's true, especially in a homophobic society like BVI, that won't be something he would be bragging and reporting to anybody.
August 01 at 1:57pm  |  Like5 People like this.   Dislike1 Person dislike this.
Jah Know | Report Abuse
Crack is one hell of a drug ! #StayAway
August 01 at 7:57am  |  Like7 People like this.   Dislike
Fresh Meat | Report Abuse
Says he was raped by the guy in prison............ so stabs him, to go back to prison for more raping?????? If that isnt a mental illness, i dont know what is.......
July 31 at 11:09pm  |  Like23 People like this.   Dislike7 People dislike this.
once they hear what he is in for this time, am sure nobody gonna wanna touch him - lol
August 01 at 4:58am  |  Like21 People like this.   Dislike
Concerned Citizen | Report Abuse
All I can say is what is next with this guy. Dennis the Menece has nothing on this guy. I try my best to avoid him because one day he cursed me out like a dog, he called me a female B and a she dog for no reason. The next day I saw him and it was as if nothing happened, he was trying to be nice... more
July 31 at 11:08pm  |  Like19 People like this.   Dislike1 Person dislike this.
patches | Report Abuse
WHAT????. This guy Matthew is a piece of work. He may be cracked out but, crack heads is the most cunning people.He is not stupid he is saying the guy raped him to get away with what he did. Matthew is playing games. Now he is resorting to say the guy raped him to shift what he did off himself.... more
July 31 at 10:27pm  |  Like15 People like this.   Dislike2 People dislike this.
Boner Stabone | Report Abuse
Nonsense...several people told him no that night and he did nothing so why he stab this particular guy? Matthew may be off his rocker a little because of vibes in life and drugs but he aint completely crazy so I BELIEVE HIM.
August 01 at 9:12am  |  Like5 People like this.   Dislike1 Person dislike this.
Please note that the comments posted are the views and opinion of the commentor and do not in any way represent the views or opinions of the management and staff of Virgin Islands Platinum News and its parent company Platinum Investors Limited.
Article Information & Controls
77 Opinions | View Opinions
Advertisement
Advertisement
- Corporate Lawyer - Bedell Cristin
Bedell | Posted: 14 May 2013
- General Manager - BVI Trust Company
BVI Trust Company | Posted: 14 May 2013
- Office Manager
Professional services firm | Posted: 10 May 2013
- General Manager
Construction/engineering company | Posted: 8 May 2013
- Experienced Legal Secretary
Mourant Ozannes | Posted: 6 May 2013
To advertise your job please contact jobs@ballastandcapel.com or click here
Job listing powered by bviemployment.com.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Marketplace
Item condition: used length owned: 4 months no scartches factory unlocked
Item condition: used length owned: 8mnths playstation 3 with two controllers.
Advertisement
Advertisement
  •   Follow us on:
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy/Legal Info.
  •   LOST - One bunch of keys, including a jeep key on an International Motors key ring. Anyone finding this bunch of keys is asked to take it to International Motors. A reward will be offered.